Sunday, February 22, 2009

Eye Openers: Summary of Reading # 24: Managing the Environmental Legacy of U.S. Nuclear-Weapons Production


From the start I found my article very interesting. It deals with nuclear weapons which all of us should know has a great deal of impact on our environment due to the radioactive material needed for production. Now don't get confused, its not talking about the USE of nuclear weapons but about the excess material lying around from production of these weapons and how are we going to manage the situation. There are six sections to my article that help in defining the situation of managing the environmental legacy of U.S. nuclear-weapons production.

Nuclear-Weapons Production

During the Cold War arms race with the Soviet Union engineering began on creating facilities that would either serve as two purposes, to recover uranium (a radioactive element used for nuclear production) from mined ore and the other for assembly, maintenance and testing. There are over 5,000 facilities constructed for those two reasons. However, the largest facilities built for the material productions and processing of radioactive elements are Hanford also known as the Idaho National Engineering and Environmental Laboratory (INEEL), Oak Ridge and Savannah River in South Carolina. Those three facilities are ones mainly discussed throughout this article. Scientists at those facilities used uranium, plutonium (a transuranic (element with greater atomic number than uranium) radioactive element) and tritium to develop these weapons. They have estimated that around the 45 years of nuclear-materials production in the U.S. there has been about 103 metric tons of weapon-grade plutonium obtained from Hanford and Savannah River. On top of that, 994 metric tons of uranium were obtained from Oak Ridge and two other small facilities. To put those numbers into perspective, one metric ton weighs 2,205 pounds. So we have a total of 2,418,885 pounds of surplus and highly hazardous nuclear weapons material that somehow has to be dealt with. Looking at a number that large of harmful material it makes me wonder how the government didn't think about only mining the amount need for production of a weapon. They plan on using some of that surplus into fuel for nuclear power plants and the rest will be disposed of in a geological repository, an underground storage unit for nuclear waste. Storing this stuff underground does not seem to be an environmentally safe solution if were looking into protecting the environment.

Environmental Consequences

2,418,885 pounds of surplus nuclear material. That of course has to have consequences on the environment. A lot of this excess material is being stored in special underground tanks at various storage sites. It has been reported that many tanks have leaked some of the material contained within. The DOE (Department of Energy) which governs the nuclear production facilities have reported that at the Oak Ridge facility which works in separating the lithium from tritium to be used for mercury (a heavy silver metal) has leaked about 110 metric tons into the Clinch River-Watts Bar Reservoir system. This reservoir happens to be used for recreation and municipal water supply. When dealing with elements used for nuclear weapons I don't see how they should make this type of mistake. The leak jeopardized a water supply and worse off it puts many people at risk of getting mercury poisoning from eat the fish. Waste material leakage isn't the only problem that has to be dealt with. Nuclear production generates waste that is directly released to the environment in the for of gases. Volatile which is vaporized gas produced during chemical processing is vented straight to our atmosphere not always being filtered. Much of the waste liquid produced from these sites is simply discharged into large surface ponds or into subsurface soil and groundwater. It is incredible how no guidelines were set up as to where or how these gases or waste liquids should be disposed of after the chemical process. Simply dispersing it into our environment does not help manage the environment. It is clear that the production of nuclear weapons exceeded the thought of waste management.

From Production to Clean-up

This section basically talks about the progression that has been made since the late 1980's and early 90's once the Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty was enacted and the Soviet Union broke up. The one that started this cleanup process is John Harrington, the energy secretary during that time. He shut down the nuclear reactor at the Hanford facility because the simply stated that the U.S. had no need for it being that the country was already "awash in plutonium." He then went onto creating the Office of Environmental Restoration and Waste Management that would establish its main mission: environmental cleanup. Although this program would not seem to accomplish milestones as quickly as hoped for. The DOE has had some successful cleanup points. A geological repository located in Carlsbad, New Mexico will help to dispose of 175,000 cubic meters of transuranic waste from nuclear weapons sites. These repository's are located 300 meters underground within a salt dome or bedrock and are said to be the home for much of the nuclear waste. It may not seem like too bad of an idea to store it in these repository's if it is going to keep the environment from being contaminated.

Reducing and Managing Risk

Described in this section of the article are the milestones that cleanup program hopes to accomplish while keeping the contamination at a minimum and employment rate constant at these facilities. However they have hit a roadblock in their attempts due to a major problem, the lack of technology to reach these milestones. In addition, the milestones hoped to be reached are not focused around protecting human and environmental health. How do you set up milestones that deal with the disposal of nuclear waste and don't focus a majority of the attention around public safety and environmental health. They are simply just laying down these milestones so that progress in the cleanup system can be measured. I think these milestones are a waste of time if the health or people and the environment are not taking into perspective.

Long-Term Stewardness

This final section simply stated that the environmental legacy of nuclear-weapons production will not be eliminated but more on the lines of being controlled. Of course it won't be able to completely be taken care of because we don't have a plan that can make the nuclear material disappear. If anything it is going to be underground, surveillanced, and maintenanced once in a while due to an occasional leak. The cleanup program is planned to continue for several decades even though there are many optimistic views. Once the right technology is developed then hopefully there will be great positive future outlooks for the environment.

My Thoughts

I found the article very interesting but a little lengthy. It was easy to understand that the author is trying to show how we have been cleaning up what has been left behind from the arms race era but yet even after a decade or more not much has been done. I think as of right now the problem is the lack of technology. Your dealing with radioactive, highly acidic and harmful material that you can not have many options in a way to dispose of the nuclear waste. The best bet would to use what you can for nuclear energy and then simply store the rest so that the total amount will drop. I wouldn't like it to be used for nuclear energy because that's just leading to more pollution but storing it underground in specialized tanks that eventually erode and leak would seem to pose more of a threat to our environment if it were to leak into a underground water bed. Overall I learned a lot from reading this article and hope that our new Secretary of Energy Stephen Chu will bring better ideas to the table.

Discussion:

Due to the little progress with the cleanup program and continuous holding of the nuclear waste at facilities , is it possible that the U.S. doesn't exactly want to conduct a full cleanup thinking that it could lead to an increased risk of a terrorist attack?

Online Sources

Yucca Nuclear Waste Site Proposal: A Bad Idea For Future Generations
By: Brooke Neuman

I found one article that talked about the plans of disposing the nuclear waste material into the Yucca Mountains in Nevada. Brooke Neuman the author of the source finds the idea of disposing the material embedded underground as simply foolish. We are simply just leaving it behind for the future generations to deal with. He states that if the proposal does pass and activation for the Yucca Mountains begins in 2010 it would still take 50 to 100 years in transporting the material. It seems that no matter what the outcome may be it is inevitable that we will be leaving the waste behind for future generations to handle.

Nuclear Waste Storage Plan Will Be Safe, Minister Says
By: Shawn McCarthy

This article contradicts what Brooke Neuman was saying about storing waste underground. The Natural Resources Minister Gary Lunn of Canada states that nuclear power repository plans are clean and safe and is the best way to handle the problem. You joking! Everything kept in those repository's is not close to being clean and safe. I'm going to have to go with Brooke Neuman on this subject being that Gary Lunn thinks storing nuclear waste in a location underground will directly be safe and clean with no negative outlook on the future at all...not even for our future generations.

Definitions


Radioactive- emitting or relating to the emission of ionizing radiation or particles

Repository- a place where things are or may be stored

Mercury- chemical element of atomic number 80, a heavy silvery white metal that is liquid at ordinary temperatures

Plutonium- a transuranic element with a fissile isotope of mass number 239 (plutonium 239) that can be produced from non-fissile uranium

Uranium- a chemical element of atomic number 92, used as a fuel in nuclear reactors

Volatile- a substance easily evaporated at normal temperatures

Methylmercury- any of several extremely toxic organometallic compounds, Hg(CH3)2, formed from metallic mercury by the action of microorganisms and capable of entering the food chain: used as seed disinfectants.

Transuranic- Having an atomic number greater than 92.

(Definitions from Dictionary.com and Mac widget dictionary)

Additional Resources

Yucca Mountain Repository
http://www.ocrwm.doe.gov/ym_repository/index.shtml

Is Everything We Use In Everyday Life Radioactive?
http://www.hps.org/publicinformation/ate/faqs/consumerproducts.html

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Eye Operners: CSPI

I started off with this eye opener by taking a Tour the Food Supply on Center for Science in Public Health website. That was quite an interesting tour. One of the most interesting facts I came upon was that 22 billing pounds of fertilizer would be capable of providing energy to 1 million Americans for a full year! I hope that sometime soon we find an environmental safe way of converting that fertilizer into energy. Something that really disgusted me was the amount of pesticides farmers are using on there crops. And some people wonder why there are consumer buying these foods and getting sick from them. Same thing with outbreaks of food borne illnesses. It is very unlikely that the slaughter house are keep clean but yet those houses are allowed to sell there product to supermarkets. A lot of interesting facts that seem to be ignored by a majority of people.

The Eating Green Calculator is a system that lets you see how your diet is compared to its affects on the environments health. I found out that the environmental burden from the animals I eat a year si 1.0 acres of grains and grass, 36.3 pounds of fertilizer, .3 pounds of pesticides, and 6323 pounds of manure produced from those animals. From my point of view I think its bad that what I eat affects the enviornment by the much. That makes me think about what impact larger people with higher food intake affect our environment. I think it would be possible for me to improve my diet. It would be harder for me during the summer times but during the winter I think it would be much easier.

I then scored my diet by taking Score Your Diet on the same website. This gave me an insight into how the food I eat is affecting the environment and animal welfare. I felt that this was not a very accurate test to take because the selection of servings it gives you in the drop down menus do not fully fit my serving amounts I usually eat. But of course I don't exactly write down my serving sizes so I had to estimate anyway. After entering my serving sizes I found that I scored the highest was in beef, vegetables, fruits, and whole grains. I ties with fruits (3) and veggies (3), with whole grains (2) coming in third and beef (0) in fourth. I had all zeros for beef because I very rarely eat beef during the winter. Now if I were to take this during the summer time when I can start up the grill my beef consumption would be much higher. As for my lowest scores, these came in cheese (-17) and milk (-6) consumption. I have to think of ways to change my impact on the environment side of food because I scored the lowest in that category. I could change that number by eating more fat-free product. Overall I had an Uh-oh score of -18...which isn't a good number to be sitting at. It says I need help so I have to try and change my diet in way that will benefit our environment and animal welfare.

All of this means to me that my diet can have a great impact on the environment. I never really thought how what I eat can impact the environment until I did this eye opener. It will make me think of ways to improve my dieting so that I can feel better about my tracks that I leave on our environment. This eye opener definitely opened up my eyes in a new way to help out the environment.

Friday, February 13, 2009

Share and Voice: Environmental Answers

Take a peak at this video...got me thinking. This video really made me glad to hear that we have certain and positive answers to energy sources that are reducing fossil fuel emissions. This video gives you an idea of a number of sources that are becoming more popular day by day. More than anything I would like to see fields of wind power turbines. I don't totally agree with them being placed in open waters but if the best wind currents are in that region and it will greatly help our environment I am okay with that. I hope Siemens AG continue to bring their innovations into production. Enjoy.

Answers For The Environment


Video linked with
Siemens.

Reflections on Week Three and Four

So another two weeks have gone by and my thoughts about the environment continue to change...in a positive way.

Week Three

Week three was an eventful week for me because I had my first review due on article 27. From that I learned how the film industry tends to depict our environment in good and bad ways, and sometimes even portray nature in a false view. It made me think about how I view these documentaries and will continue to view them, most likely thinking more in depth about whats behind the scenes. Another group reviewed article number 1, which talked about the environmental challenges that we face.

Week Four

Week four in class was very relaxing. We watched the documentary film An Inconvenient Truth by Al Gore. It gave insight into the threatening and devastating troubles that global warming is having on our planet. Troubles that are affecting people and our environment. I thought it was a very well directed film and I believe Al Gore has made a huge step in getting people to follow along with the fact that global warming is real and we need to do something about it before its to late.

These past four weeks have been a learning experience getting me to think about the environment in ways that I really don't sit down and take the time ponder about.

Sunday, February 8, 2009

Eye Openers: Ecoogical Footprint


After taking the Ecological Footprint quiz, probably the most interesting thing I found out is that if everyone lived the way I do we would need 4.4 planets to provide everyone with enough resources. Holy smokes, that's a lot. To add to that, it would take 19.7 global acres of Earth's productive area to support the way I live. What really struck me is that, having 19.7 global acres would result in 21.1 tons of carbon dioxide a year. Being that we would need 4.4 planets to provide enough resources if everyone lived the way I do makes me hope that there is a lot of people who may be living a more resource valued life to make up for my usage. I'll be thinking of ways to lower my rate of 4.4 planets. The use of electricity was the highest when I looked at what I use to support my lifestyle. Of course electricity will be the highest for mostly everyone but it reminds me that I have to do what I can to conserve that energy and use it to the very least. I know I forget to shutdown my computer for the night or leave the TV on when I'm not even watching it. Those are things I will change.

The second quiz I took was the Score Your Diet quiz. I thought this was a pretty useful tool in judging how well you diet yourself. I think to many people are to busy to actually pay attention to their diet so I find tools like this helpful to give me an insight on what I should maybe eat more or less of. I found out that I should be eating more fish and less beef. I grew up with my paps pretty much cooking meals with meat in them probably 70 percent of the time so that's been past on into my cooking abilities. My health score was a 7, while my environmental score was a -11 and my animal welfare score was a -6. For some reason I feel like those numbers are necessarily right but It's hard to select exactly how many servings you had of what. Either way it makes me think of how to improve my diet. Guess I'll be thinking of new meals to cook.

The third quiz I took was the Transport Impact Calculator. Once I started taking it I thought I would have a much worse impact on generating emissions but I found out that my annual pollution for road transport is better than average. Good thing I have a car that gets nearly 30 mpg. Thanks Toyota. I generate the most pollution while on trips to visit family, make sense to me since they live about four and half hours away. My sollution to cutting my emission rate is to car pool more often and to catch the bus more than what I have been doing.

I found these three quizes very helpful. They've made me realize a lot of what I do effects the environment. Not only that but what I'm doing I need to change so that I can have more of a positive effect on our planet. I will always be thinking of ways to go greener.

Thursday, February 5, 2009

Share and Voice: Tidal Power

Hey Everyone,

I found this article about a new form of power that Scotland is working on. It talks about the using a tidal wave turbine to capture energy from waves! So far a corporation in Scotland has completed what seems to be the prototype to hopefully determine if they can expand production on this idea. Of course if this does work I'm guessing that this power will not be able to be transferred farther into the cities but if it helps in power the cities near the ocean shore....just another step towards a renewable energy source. Surf's Up To Energy!

Check it out at http://www.ecogeek.org/content/view/2537/84/

I found this article on another blog called ecogeek.

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Review of Reading 27: Seeing Green: Knowing and Saving the Environment on Film


Seeing Green: Know and Saving the Environment on Film, this was quite an interesting piece of reading. I believe what this article was trying to accomplish is to give the reader a sense of how the mass media depicts its role in establishing and conveying environmental problems and solutions. It goes into depth on the topics of natural processes, environmental degradation and solutions from filmmakers making these documentaries. Because mass media plays a large role on our society many of these documentary films are going to affect the viewers.

These filmmakers are able to display a rain forest disappearing or wildlife in danger and get people into taking action on these problems. A lot of it is due to the dramatic feeling that can be captured from watching these films. Think of the difference, if you are simply told that over in the Amazon Rain Forest trees are being cut down by the hundreds each day. Is this going to have the same effect on you as if you were to view it happening on film and tied in with dramatic music?

The Fantasies of Natural History Film


Much of us will watch a film on the environment and only take in and believe what we see, not what may really be there. For example, the article states that a film that shows a cheetah in dead sprint to catch a gazelle in an open field looks secluded from the world but do we really know what surrounds that area. There may be a van of tourists, roads nearby, or even power lines. So when we view this film we get a sense that the scene is taking place in an untouched, unpopulated, and uncivilized area. It seems as if they do this to mislead us in how our planet really looks like. Possibly the point of them doing this is to comfort us so that we THINK that environement is what it use to be and not becoming.

Framing Environmental Degradation

I would like to go over one of the many films this section talks about. The film is called On Natures Terms (de Graaf 2001). This film shows the life of large predatory mammals in the United States. The main point for this film is that mammals such as wolves, pumas, and bears are "keystone species," which means they are critical indicators to a healthy ecosystem. They get this label because these mammals require so much land and are able to regulate the population of other animals. Due to government polices and suburban sprawl is contributing to the decline in population levels of those three animals, causing a domino effect into ruining the ecosystem health. This film shows just that and how citizens are taking actions into conserve the land and preserve the species but doesn't show any change in attitudes of Americans thoughts on predator loss. You have to be able to show attitude in order to have an impact on others to change thier attitude about the problem and commit to finding a solution. Another interesting point I found in this section was about a Malaysian logging company is cutting and exporting tropical timber on a Solomon Island called Rendova. It goes on to talk about a group called Haforai Development Corporation, villagers of this group are not sure whether to resign a contract to allow them to continue cutting down trees basically because there has been a steep decline in the tropical tree resources on the island. It confuses me to think that these people must have not thought what may happen after continous exportation of thier resrouces. According to one logger interviewd "the devestation of logging is obvious and what once use to be a clear river is now muddy." Such continous acts of degradation will be very detrimental to our planet.

Visualizing Green Crusades


The green crusades reference the films that are entirely up to saving the environment or atleast raise questions about what strategies will work. These films try to illustrate that knowledge on environemental practices are based on social orders and hierarchies, and the role of individuals promoting structural change. The film Save the Panda (Birch 1983) says it all in the title. The goal is to catalyst individuals to take there own actions on saving China's pandas which are still on the road to extinction. It sets the path for people to take action but many people just aren't sure how to go about that path. Setting up signs to tell poachers about the consequences won't get us anywhere. Although these films may encourage peope to act, I just don't feel many people do, they think others will take action. This section didn't give to much insight into solutions that would hopefully lead to green crusades.

I Pondered...

This article contained quite a bit of information so I had to read through it twice but I stil don't think I fully understand everything on the pages. What really made me think was the section about the Malaysian logging company and the villagers of Rendova. It seems to me that this still occurs in our world today. We are cutting down trees and its like DUH!, we don't even get what were doing. The villagers only realize the damage to there environment when its to late. Also I guess I never thought of what may be cut out of scences when I view a documentary like Planet Earth (A MUST SEE) or any othere, there may be roads or power lines or a town nearby. We accept to much of what we see and not the reality. That has made me to be more aware of what mass media is feeding us.